When doing reviews, I find it useful to have a point of comparison so I listened to Expansion Pack 2.0 and then listened to Blast Furnace. Blast Furnace was good, but this is much more varied in style and a lot less predictable. It also reminded me that Blast Furnace wasn’t just straight up rhythmic noise. That’s the nice thing about Scott Sturgis – it’s difficult to pigeonhole him into one category. If you get this disc, think of it in terms of not only expanding your collection of Sturgis’s output, but also in terms of expanding what you think of Converter. I have to admit that when I got these discs I thought that I was in for rhythmic noise – until I read the press sheet that came with it. I’ll quote from that here: "this expansion contains unreleased material, live tracks and remixes by industrial icons like Sonar and ambient masters like Architect and Displacer." Ambient? Converter? Yes, and it's really good.
On with the music; let’s start with disc 1. First off, this opens with what can best be described as harsh ambient - voices talking about subliminal messages and bits of noise thrown in. About 6 minutes in you are reminded that you did not put the wrong disc in the CD player as it kicks into the rhythmic noise that you had expected. A nice opening to the disc. Track 2 is Domination which, from the press release is a something that people like in clubs. Because I’m out of the club scene, I don’t know, but it does sound like it would work well. The rest of the disc alternates between these extremes – sedate, more mellow pieces and harsh rhythmic noise. About the only real low point on the disc was "Witch Hunter (Burned Remix by DJ Burn)" which was a bit too repetitive with a steady 4/4 beat running through it. Even though Witch Hunter (Hanged) is not up to the rest of the disc either, it at least changes it up a bit and is a minute and a half shorter.
Disc 2 begins with "Atlantis (1990 re-edit)" a shorter, more minimal track of some spoken word that is difficult to understand and eases into track 2, "Time Through Windows" which is a more sedate, tribal sounding track. Although repetitive, there is enough happening beneath the surface to keep it interesting. This was actually one of my favorite tracks. It’s not until track 5, "Electric Wizard" that the rhythmic noise kicks back in and I have to admit that I was enjoying the soundscapes more. The press sheet tells DJs to play Monster Death for the "party people" and I have to agree – this would sound right at home on the dance floor and at 9.31 it gives the DJ plenty of time to flirt with the clubbers (isn’t that what the DJs are actually after anyway?). This disc is also a good mix of less aggressive tracks (although keep in mind that this is still Converter that we’re talking about, so it’s all relative) and the rhythmic noise we expect from Converter.
Overall this is a good set - and weighing in at about 2.5 hours of music, the discs are packed about as full as possible. The only real issue I have is that I would have preferred a set that had the low key stuff on one disc and the noisy stuff on the other to more easily suit the mood I’m in. Other than that, this is really good and both discs (especially disc 2) will be spending some quality time in my CD player.