The Chicago independent scene of the early 2000s was an accommodating place for musical eccentricity, provided nobody expected the results to fit neatly into a record-shop category. Michael Columbia emerged from that environment as an offshoot of David McDonnell's work with Bablicon, and their latest album, "Mirrors, Shapes, Objects", suggests that the intervening years have done little to improve their respect for stylistic boundaries. Free jazz, post-rock, electronic experimentation, psychedelic repetition and something approaching conventional songwriting all make an appearance. The remarkable thing is not that these ingredients coexist, but that the trio has learned how to make them interact without turning every track into a referendum on musical identity.
The group brings together three musicians whose careers have taken them through rather different corners of the American underground. McDonnell, responsible here for synthesizers, bass, soprano and alto saxophones, and vocals, began his recording career with Bablicon, the Elephant 6-affiliated collective in which he performed as the Diminisher. He subsequently became involved with Herculaneum, Icy Demons and numerous projects spanning jazz, rock and electronic composition. He is also a composer, computer-music programmer and educator, currently teaching music technology at Temple University. Christopher Kalis contributes synthesizers, guitar and bass, drawing on his experience with Chicago hardware-based groups such as Chandeliers, Songs for Gods and Drasii. Drummer Dylan Ryan, meanwhile, has worked with an impressive range of artists, including Red Krayola, Cursive, Bitchin Bajas, Jeff Parker and Jeremiah Chiu. Their previous association in Icy Demons provides some historical continuity, but "Mirrors, Shapes, Objects" sounds less like a reunion than the meeting of three musicians who have accumulated enough different experiences to make their old partnership newly productive.
The album's nine tracks are mostly concise, rarely exceeding six minutes. This is a significant decision for a group operating in territory where instrumental freedom can sometimes become an excuse for allowing compositions to outlive their welcome. Michael Columbia favour compact structures, frequently introducing vocal passages or recurring melodic ideas before the music moves into more exploratory territory. The result is a record with the restless intelligence of progressive music but without the obligatory twenty-minute excursion into a keyboard solo that requires its own postal address.
“Eagles of the Sea” establishes the approach with an infectious, slightly elusive rhythmic pattern. A recurring sample provides a loose framework, while Ryan's drumming brings a lively, almost mischievous energy to the arrangement. McDonnell's vocals are understated, allowing the soprano saxophone to take over as the piece develops. His playing is agile without becoming overly demonstrative, weaving around the rhythm with a fluidity that recalls the more adventurous side of early-1970s jazz-rock. The composition's appeal comes from the way its components retain their independence while remaining attentive to one another. The electronic elements are not simply decoration, and the saxophone is not there to certify the group's jazz credentials. Everyone has a job, and nobody appears particularly interested in applying for a promotion.
“Red Paint” moves towards a more recognisable song format. Kalis' guitar refrain has a distinctly angular quality, while McDonnell's vocal delivery suggests a relaxed art-rock sensibility. Beneath the relatively accessible surface, however, the lyrics evoke the disoriented consciousness of the protagonist in Jim Jarmusch's "Dead Man", whose journey through an unfamiliar landscape is as much psychological as physical. The trio handles this material with considerable restraint, avoiding the temptation to make the music as overtly dramatic as its subject matter. “Speed Boat” subsequently shifts the balance towards instrumental propulsion, with interlocking rhythms and electronic textures generating a more pronounced psychedelic momentum. Its title may suggest carefree aquatic recreation, but the musical experience is closer to discovering that the boat has developed an independent opinion about navigation.
“The Ghola” is one of the album's most effective instrumental constructions. Its pulsing synthesiser patterns and motorik rhythm section create a hypnotic framework, with the trio gradually expanding the arrangement through subtle shifts in density and emphasis. The title refers to the fictional concept of a reconstructed human being in Frank Herbert's "Dune" universe, an appropriate reference for a composition that seems to assemble its identity from previously existing musical materials. “Maid of Metal” explores a similarly electronic terrain, but with a more flexible rhythmic design. Kalis' use of unsynchronised arpeggios and delay patterns gives the synthesiser lines a pleasantly unpredictable character. Rather than locking every component to a rigid digital grid, the musicians allow the patterns to interact with the live rhythm section, creating a sense of movement that is both precise and slightly unruly.
“Diana” offers another shift in emphasis. Its melodic contours and instrumental interplay reveal the trio's ability to construct a memorable composition without abandoning their experimental instincts. There is an attractive balance between atmosphere and rhythmic definition, with the electronics providing depth while the acoustic instruments keep the arrangement physically grounded. “Hunted by Cougars” takes a more oblique route, its title suggesting a particularly unfortunate outdoor excursion. The music is more concerned with instrumental interplay than narrative illustration, allowing the saxophone, synthesizers and drums to move through a series of changing accents and textures. The humour of the title is welcome, particularly on an album whose musical vocabulary can otherwise become rather serious about its own intellectual credentials.
“Lady Midnight” returns to a more song-oriented approach. Its darker lyrical premise, centred on a duchess experiencing feverish visions during the Hundred Years' War, is matched by a more forceful opening passage. Kalis' guitar and the rhythm section establish a dramatic tension, while McDonnell's measured vocals prevent the composition from becoming an exercise in historical melodrama. The track also demonstrates how comfortably the trio can move between progressive-rock arrangements and new-wave sensibilities. There are echoes of Peter Gabriel's early solo work in the vocal phrasing, but the instrumental language remains distinctly more exploratory.
The closing title track has an unusual history. Originally recorded on reel-to-reel tape nearly twenty years ago, it was rediscovered by McDonnell on an old hard drive and subsequently completed with a new vocal part. Its pulsing bass synthesizers and heavily delayed saxophone preserve something of the atmosphere of Chicago's experimental music scene during the period when the group first emerged. Rather than sounding like an archival curiosity awkwardly attached to a contemporary album, the composition fits surprisingly well. Its presence also reinforces the idea that Michael Columbia is an ongoing creative process, not simply a project revived for the sake of revisiting earlier achievements. The past is allowed into the room, but it does not get to dictate the furniture arrangement.
The recording history of the album is itself revealing. Most of the material was recorded in December 2024, while “The Ghola” and the title track draw on earlier unfinished sessions that were subsequently reworked. This combination of recent compositions and older material gives the record a certain temporal breadth without making it feel like a collection of unrelated leftovers. The trio's years apart have clearly mattered: each member has developed an individual musical vocabulary, and those experiences now feed into a partnership that is more flexible than it might have been during its earlier incarnation.
There are occasional moments when the album's stylistic variety threatens to become a little too comfortable with its own eclecticism. Some of the vocal passages feel more conventional than the surrounding instrumental material, and a few transitions could have been developed further. Yet the decision to keep the compositions relatively short proves largely beneficial. Instead of allowing technical ability to dominate, Michael Columbia focus on the identity of each piece, giving the listener a succession of distinct musical situations rather than one extended demonstration of instrumental competence. The references to Can, King Crimson, Soft Machine and the more experimental side of art-rock are understandable, but they remain points of orientation rather than destinations.
"Mirrors, Shapes, Objects" is a convincing return from a group whose history has been defined by experimentation, interruption and reinvention. Its greatest strength is the relationship between composition and improvisation: the music has enough structure to remain memorable, but enough freedom to avoid sounding overly predetermined. McDonnell, Kalis and Ryan have developed a shared language that accommodates both the pleasures of a well-shaped song and the unpredictable energy of musicians responding to one another in real time. It is a record that values curiosity over stylistic loyalty, and musical personality over the increasingly tedious business of declaring allegiance to a genre. The title may promise three separate categories of perception, but Michael Columbia seem more interested in what happens when all three are placed on the same table and nobody bothers to label them.