A "whimbrel" is a robust, large shorebird in the sandpiper family with a very long, curved bill and relatively long neck and legs which has little to do conceptually with this band. The Whimbrels are a New York City based band with an NYC pedigree, 3 guitarists, 1 bassist and 1 drummer. The pedigree comes from involvement with other projects - longtime Swans member Norm Westberg, Arad Evans (Glenn Branca Ensemble)), and Luke Schwartz (Glenn Branca, Whaton Tiers Ensemble). The lesser-knowns are bassist Matt Hunter (New Radiant Storm King, Matt Hunter and the Dusty Fates, among others) and drummer Steve Dibenedetto (downtown artist better known for his paintings than being in name bands) round out the roster. So what kind of music do we have on 'The Whimbrels' self-titled debut album? Well, they call themselves a "power art rock" band, but musicians were never spot on at genre classifications; that seems to be the domain of music writers. Then again I suppose any genre mash-up could work on the extended plan, but I see this outfit as more No Wave with touches of experimental and noise, just trying to fit them into our genre parameters somewhere. Their inclusion for review here is partly due to the persistent efforts of their publicist, sending me real product, and the roots of their music careers. Would we deny Swans a review because they don't fit into a comfortable genre nook? Hell no. Never have, never will. But this is certainly not Swans-like by any stretch of the imagination.
An album of merely seven track in about 38 minutes, the album opens with strumming guitar riffs on "She is the Leader," before it settles into a rhythmic groove. Can't help but think of Joy Division on this one, until the storytelling vocals come in. (BTW, both Arad and Matt handle vocal duties.) The song is amiable and engaging, and has anticipated break with a bit of noisy experimentalism. What's not to like here? "Monarchs" suffers from understated vocals but I though the bass lines were pretty cool. About halfway through it changes pacer and turns into something else a bit slower, but I wasn't convinced. More abstract and disjunct is "Distant Land," a change of pace from jangly rhythms with spoke-sung vocals on the verse, and a little more melodic on the chorus. The Frippish sustained guitar lines helped this one, but one again, understated vocals lacking personality don't help. Now for a crazy post-punk rocker - "That's How It Was," reminds me of the many bands I saw at Max's Kansas City, CBGB's and elsewhere in the mid-to-late '70s. Vocals on this one are very upfront and it has an absolutely raw and alive sound. Keeping up the momentum with "Scream For Me" I hear everything from the Velvets to the Stooges but again the vocal is a bit anemic. The mysteriously spooky 'Eclipse Eye" works on all levels as the subdued vocals perfectly fit the tensely atmospheric music, and just might be the surprise standout of the album. It loses a bit atmospherically when the rhythm is bolstered, but returns to the fold before the end. So with the finale, "Four Moons of Galileo," we get a big hammer-'n-strum buildup from the wall of guitars before launching into something almost completely different, jammy and improvisational. Gears are shifted rhythmically again to other riffs, and the direction is...well, elsewhere? lost?
The album sounds self-produced and I think suffers for it. These guys had some good ideas, and probably had a good time doing it, but there is just not enough standout material to capture the ears of new listeners among the gazillion choice out there. Not bad, but could have been better.