The title already does most of the work. It asks a question, then refuses to answer it properly. Which is exactly the kind of behavior you would expect from Rie Nakajima and David Toop when left alone with time, emails, and an inconvenient global pause.
This project grows out of lockdown conversations, which sounds like a warning label, but turns out to be a strength. Confined situations tend to either flatten thought or sharpen it. Here, thought drifts, loops, sidesteps itself. Nakajima and Toop don’t use isolation as a dramatic backdrop. They treat it as a condition that alters attention. Things float away. Other things become strangely fixed. Sound behaves like memory does when it’s left unsupervised.
Both artists arrive with long histories of refusing rigid categories. Nakajima’s work has consistently treated everyday objects and fragile sounds as instruments that barely agree to exist. Toop, for decades now, has operated somewhere between music, writing, ethnography, improvisation, and gentle provocation. Together, they don’t collaborate so much as coexist, leaving space for accidents, humour, and partial listening.
The idea of sculpture hangs over the record like a polite misunderstanding. Sculpture is supposed to be solid, heavy, durable. This music is none of those things. Instead, it unfolds as duration, as gesture, as something that briefly takes shape and then moves on without asking permission. If there is mass here, it’s temporal. If there is weight, it’s attentional.
Across the four parts, sound behaves like a collection of small events that never demand hierarchy. Percussive ticks, airy resonances, quiet scrapes, near-silences. Nothing insists on being central. Part I introduces the logic gently, almost conversationally. By Part II and III, the listening deepens. You start noticing how often you stop trying to “follow” and simply let the sounds pass through, like light shifting across a room.
The long final part stretches this sensibility without urgency. At nearly half an hour, it never announces itself as a climax. Instead, it tests patience in a friendly way. Sounds appear, disappear, reappear altered. You might miss something. That’s fine. The record is comfortable with being partially ignored, which is rare and oddly generous.
Humour is present, but quietly. Not punchlines, more the amusement of two people enjoying how strange serious ideas become when you look at them from the side. The notion that a season could be a sculpture is absurd until you realize how much effort goes into pretending it isn’t. Spring arrives, changes everything, then leaves. No pedestal required.
The accompanying book matters here. Photographs, fragments, and visual traces don’t explain the music. They echo its logic. Documentation without authority. Evidence without conclusion. The design keeps things light, deliberately unmonumental.
Mastered by Lawrence English with a careful hand, the sound preserves fragility rather than polishing it away. Room40 continues to be exactly the right home for work that values listening as an active, slightly unreliable process.
"Is Spring A Sculpture?" doesn’t argue its case. It suggests. It lingers. It trusts that if you spend enough time with it, the question will stop feeling abstract and start feeling practical. You might not be able to touch these sculptures, but they have a way of rearranging how you notice things afterward. Which, inconveniently, is often the point.