«« ⟺ »»

Music Reviews

Darkswoon: Antivenom

More reviews by
Artist: Darkswoon (@)
Title: Antivenom
Format: CD & 12" + Download
Label: Viasonde
Rated: * * * * *
There are albums that use darkness as an aesthetic, and then there are albums that have clearly spent some time finding out what darkness actually costs. "Antivenom", the fourth full-length by Portland trio Darkswoon, belongs to the second category. Its title suggests a cure, but the music is more interested in what happens when the poison has already entered the bloodstream: grief, fear, alienation, anxiety, political exhaustion, damaged relationships, the uneasy business of remaining a person while the surrounding world keeps providing reasons not to bother. Fortunately, Darkswoon have enough musical intelligence not to turn any of this into a sermon. They make beautiful songs about difficult things, which is considerably harder than making miserable music about difficult things.

Darkswoon began as Jana Cushman’s solo project before evolving into the trio heard here, with Cushman on vocals and guitar, Rachel Ellis handling synths, keys, drum machines and rhythm programming, and Norah Lynn supplying bass. That history remains audible in the band's unusual balance between electronic construction and intimate songwriting. The rhythmic machinery can feel precise and almost impersonal, while the bass and guitar continually pull the songs back toward something physical. Cushman's voice occupies the unstable middle ground between the two: airy without becoming fragile, dramatic without resorting to the theatrical excess that gothic music occasionally mistakes for emotional depth. Recent writing on the album has similarly highlighted the way the trio has tightened its identity around darkwave, post-punk, shoegaze and electronic music without allowing those categories to dictate the songs.

The album announces its intentions with "Connective Tissue", a brief instrumental fragment that is less an introduction than a piece of connective material in the literal sense. It is noise, atmosphere and transition compressed into forty seconds. The idea is significant because Darkswoon repeatedly treat the spaces between things as musically meaningful. The band have explained that this kind of passage also reflects what happens during their live performances, when the noise created by Lynn's effects and the preparation of Ellis's electronic setup becomes part of the performance rather than dead time between songs. The record consequently begins not with a declaration but with something half-formed, as if we have walked into a room before everyone has finished setting up.

Then comes "Antivenom", and the album's emotional stakes become clearer. The song was written in response to the death of Nex Benedict and expands from personal grief toward the broader vulnerability experienced by trans people in a hostile political climate. Cushman conceived the title around the idea of music as a counter-agent to the poisons circulating through contemporary life. It is an unusually direct piece of political songwriting for a band whose music otherwise tends toward ambiguity, yet Darkswoon avoid turning the track into a slogan. The electronic pulse gives it a controlled urgency, while the guitars widen the emotional field around Cushman's voice. The result is not optimism, exactly. It is closer to protective instinct converted into sound.

"Pacific City" changes the temperature. Written during a solitary retreat on the Oregon coast, it carries the peculiar quality of music produced away from one's ordinary surroundings, when isolation can be restorative for about twenty minutes before the brain remembers that it came along for the trip. Its atmosphere is more open, but Darkswoon never confuse openness with weightlessness. The bass remains crucial, providing a melodic undertow beneath Ellis' programmed rhythms and Cushman's layers of guitar. That combination gives the music an interesting physical contradiction: the upper frequencies seem to float while the lower ones keep insisting that gravity still exists.

"Thread" is perhaps the clearest demonstration of how effectively Darkswoon can combine songcraft with accumulation. Its central image of a relationship held together by something increasingly difficult to distinguish from a wound is perfectly suited to the band's arrangement. The rhythm keeps moving, the bass pushes forward, guitars spread outward, while Cushman's vocal remains suspended between attachment and exhaustion. Rather than building toward a conventional cathartic release, the track keeps tightening its emotional knot. It is post-punk not because it sounds like an archaeological reconstruction of 1981, but because tension is allowed to remain tension. The track's move toward shoegaze scale has been noted by several contemporary reviewers, but what matters is that the expansion never swallows the underlying song.

That distinction is important across "Antivenom". Darkswoon understand that atmosphere only becomes interesting when there is something underneath it. There are plenty of records in the darkwave and shoegaze neighbourhood where the guitars become enormous and the vocals dissolve into reverb until everyone involved seems to have forgotten what the song was about. Here the opposite happens. The production gives the emotional content more room to operate. Norah Lynn's bass is especially effective because it does not merely mark the bottom of the mix: it behaves melodically, often providing the movement that prevents the songs from becoming static tableaux. Ellis' electronic percussion supplies a harder skeleton, while Cushman's guitars create the surrounding pressure.

"Monochrome" exploits this contrast particularly well. Its title implies reduction, yet the music is anything but flat. The track's emotional world is built from gradations rather than dramatic colour changes, allowing small shifts in texture and intensity to become significant. "Small Death" is more intimate and unsettling, while "Devour My Eyes" pushes further into the band's ability to make density feel simultaneously attractive and vaguely dangerous. The title itself suggests consumption, and the music seems to understand that attraction and threat are not necessarily opposites. Sometimes the beautiful thing is precisely what you should probably stop staring at.

"Blood Let" is one of the album's most complicated pieces because its musical history mirrors its subject. Cushman originally conceived it as a slower ballad before the band dismantled and reconstructed the material. The final version deals with abandonment, disillusionment, the uneasy relationship between mind and body, and the physical experience that inspired part of its imagery. What could have become an overly literal confessional instead acquires a strangely fragmented momentum. The song sounds as though it is trying to put itself back together while simultaneously questioning whether the original shape deserves to survive.

Then comes "x3", the album's most overtly political and arguably most abrasive moment. Its perspective broadens from private damage toward ecological collapse, inequality, concentrated wealth and the fear of what kind of future is being prepared by people who appear remarkably confident that consequences are a problem for somebody else. The band's response is not subtle, and it does not need to be. The track has the feeling of an alarm that has been ringing for so long that silence would now be more disturbing than noise. Yet even here Darkswoon retain their sense of structure. The anger is channelled rather than sprayed across the walls.

The closing "Going Dark" is consequently more interesting than a simple descent into despair. It considers withdrawal, the desire to disappear from systems that seem increasingly hostile, and the possibility of finding value outside the logic of scarcity and acquisition. But the song remains ambivalent about disappearance. There is a pull toward retreat and another toward staying. That unresolved tension is one of the album's defining qualities. Darkswoon do not manufacture closure because the subjects they address do not conveniently come with an eleventh track called "Everything Is Fine Now". The album ends with uncertainty still breathing.

There is a slight danger in a record this committed to a consistent emotional climate: several songs inhabit similar tempos, densities and tonal colours, and one contemporary review has pointed out that individual tracks can occasionally blur into the larger sequence. Yet in "Antivenom" that continuity also serves a purpose. These songs feel less like ten separate episodes than different rooms in the same troubled house. You can move from one to another, but the atmosphere follows you.

What ultimately makes the album work is that Darkswoon never confuse vulnerability with weakness. Cushman's lyrics can be painfully exposed, but the arrangements refuse to sentimentalise them. The cold electronics, muscular bass, programmed rhythms and increasingly expansive guitars provide resistance around the voice. The songs therefore become places where fragility has to coexist with structure. Even the record's most beautiful passages have something slightly clenched inside them.

"Antivenom" does not really offer an antidote to anything. That would be too easy, and probably rather insulting to anyone who has actually had to live through the things these songs describe. What it offers instead is a form of chemical counterpressure: sound meeting poison without pretending to neutralise it completely. The wounds remain visible. So does fear. So does anger. But so does connection, stubbornly refusing to die.

For a band working in music traditionally associated with beautifully arranged misery, that may be Darkswoon's most useful trick. They do not make darkness comfortable. They make it articulate.



Jake Muir: Pareidolia

More reviews by
Artist: Jake Muir (@)
Title: Pareidolia
Format: 12" + Download
Label: enmossed
Rated: * * * * *
There is a delicious absurdity in the idea behind Jake Muir’s "Pareidolia": take the most atmospheric fragments from hundreds of death-metal and black-metal records, remove most of the things that would normally identify them as metal, slow them down until their bones become difficult to recognise, and then ask the listener to believe that something heavy is still happening. It sounds like an elaborate prank on genre taxonomy. It turns out to be considerably more serious than that.

The title provides the key. Pareidolia is the tendency to discover recognisable forms in random patterns: faces in clouds, animals in stains, divine apparitions in burnt toast, presumably Satan in an unfortunate patch of bathroom mould. Muir applies the same perceptual trick to sound. He wants us to hear metal where the obvious evidence of metal has largely disappeared. The riffs are no longer riffs in any conventional sense, the vocals have been reduced to spectral matter, the guitars become geological formations, and rhythm frequently evaporates altogether. Yet the music retains an unmistakable sense of menace.

Muir is particularly well suited to this kind of forensic listening. The Los Angeles-based artist, DJ and field recordist has built much of his practice around found sound and the transformation of material whose original context is gradually obscured. His previous work has moved through such unlikely territories as church bells and vintage erotic-film soundtracks, while "Talisman", his 2022 collaboration with Evan Caminiti, helped push him toward processing guitar and reconsidering his longstanding relationship with rock music. "Pareidolia" feels like the logical consequence of that investigation: less a tribute to metal than an archaeological excavation of the places where metal stops behaving like metal.

This distinction matters. Muir is not sampling the spectacular bits. There are no heroic solos here, no blast-beat fireworks, no growled declarations demanding that somebody open the gates of hell immediately. Instead, he has gone after the margins: introductions, interludes, atmospheric passages, sustained guitar textures and other moments that metal listeners may regard as connective tissue. By isolating them, he discovers that the supposedly secondary material was carrying an enormous amount of the genre’s emotional architecture all along.

"Beithir" establishes the method with a certain slyness. What might once have functioned as a prelude becomes the event itself. Guitar-derived textures stretch beyond their original proportions, losing the reassuring coordinates of song form. The sound is heavy without having to demonstrate heaviness. "Necrotic Mist" continues the process, with its title practically doing some of the listener's interpretive work in advance. The music itself is more ambiguous: something seems to be emerging from the murk, but every attempt to identify it makes it dissolve further.

Then comes "Unholy Apparitions", where Muir's sense of sonic misdirection becomes particularly effective. Foley-like noises, distorted vocal residues and unstable textures seem to occupy different layers of reality. Nothing quite announces its source. Instead of asking “What am I hearing?”, the track encourages the more irrational question “What does this sound resemble?” That small psychological shift is precisely where pareidolia begins.

"Oblivion" is among the album’s most convincing demonstrations of Muir’s central argument. Its slow-moving, doom-laden weight has the physical presence associated with extreme metal, but without the aggression normally required to communicate it. The piece does not attack. It looms. This is an important distinction, because "Pareidolia" repeatedly suggests that volume and heaviness are not synonymous. A sound can be enormous while remaining almost motionless. It can feel oppressive without actually becoming loud.

This is where the album brushes against dark ambient, drone and the more experimental descendants of industrial music. Comparisons with Lustmord are understandable, particularly because both artists understand that darkness can be constructed through scale, resonance and subtraction rather than through sheer sonic violence. But Muir's particular achievement is to retain a peculiar metallic tension inside those otherwise ambient structures. The guitars may have been chemically processed beyond recognition, yet something of their original threat survives.

"Each Uisge" makes the transformation almost beautiful. High-pitched guitar fragments rise over choral-like pads, while small vocal disturbances appear and vanish before they can become language. The title refers to a water spirit from Scottish folklore, and the music has an appropriately unstable quality: attractive enough to approach, strange enough to make approaching it seem like a questionable life decision.

"Celestial Visions" offers one of the album's more luminous passages, although Muir never allows brightness to become comfort. This is not ambient music designed to improve the user's morning routine, increase productivity or help them discover their inner chakras while answering emails. Its moments of beauty remain contaminated by the material from which they were extracted. The celestial is never entirely separated from the necrotic.

That tension becomes especially potent on "Anima". Here the decelerated metal vocabulary seems to acquire an almost sensual quality. Heavy guitar residues and metallic clatter are transformed into something slower, warmer and strangely intimate. It is a reminder that Muir's work has never been particularly interested in keeping genres in their assigned emotional departments. Eroticism can coexist with decay; tenderness can emerge from distortion; a black-metal guitar can become almost voluptuous once somebody stops insisting that it behave like a black-metal guitar.

The closing "Cathedral of Decay" gathers these contradictions rather beautifully. Its title sounds like something that should be printed in Gothic lettering on a shirt sold by a man who has not seen daylight since 1997, but the music itself is much more elusive. The “cathedral” is not a building so much as a spatial effect, constructed from resonance and distance. And “decay” is not simply horror. It is transformation, the gradual loss of a thing's original identity until another form becomes possible.

This is perhaps what separates "Pareidolia" from a clever sampling exercise. Muir is not simply demonstrating that metal contains ambient music. He is asking what remains of a genre once its recognisable gestures have been stripped away. If you remove the drums, the growls, the riff structures, the theatrical aggression and the cultural uniforms, can the underlying emotional substance survive?

His answer is an unexpectedly confident yes.

In fact, the album suggests something more provocative: perhaps some of metal's most powerful qualities were never located in its loudness at all. They were in its fascination with vastness, dread, ritual, repetition, altered states and sounds that seem to come from somewhere older and less hospitable than ordinary human life. Once those qualities are isolated, they do not necessarily need distortion pedals or a drummer with a personal vendetta against silence.

Muir's real sleight of hand, then, is not turning metal into ambient music. It is making us reconsider how little metal actually needs in order to remain metal.

"Pareidolia" leaves behind a strange residue, like finding an ancient symbol in a patch of moss and then becoming mildly concerned that the moss has noticed you. The original records are mostly invisible. Their identities have been blurred, stretched, liquefied and rearranged. Yet their emotional fingerprints remain.

Heavy music, Muir discovers, does not necessarily require impact. Sometimes all it needs is the suspicion that something enormous is hiding inside the fog.



hackedpicciotto: Lichtung

More reviews by
Artist: hackedpicciotto (http://www.hackedepicciotto.de/) (@)
Title: Lichtung
Format: LP
Label: Mute (@)
Rated: * * * * *
There is something almost suspicious about an album called "Lichtung" arriving after fourteen years of wandering. A clearing, after all, is not simply a piece of land where the trees happen to be missing. It is a place made visible by an interruption: the forest opens, the horizon returns, and for once nobody has to keep walking. For hackedepicciotto, that distinction matters. Danielle de Picciotto and Alexander Hacke have spent much of their shared artistic life in motion, allowing churches, cities, recording studios and temporary homes to become part of their music. Now they have returned to Berlin, settled on its outer edge, and apparently discovered the radical avant-garde potential of having an address.

"Lichtung" is therefore a homecoming record, but not a cosy one. The forest has been cleared, not domesticated.

The title track establishes this beautifully. Piano, violin, electronics and Hacke's low-frequency presence create an atmosphere that feels neither ambient nor traditionally song-based. There is an almost ritual quality to it, but without the usual incense-and-new-age baggage. The German lyrics move through amethyst, opal, berries, pomegranates, animals, flowers and fire before arriving at the album's central opposition: outside, storms; inside, a place where fear temporarily loses its jurisdiction. The imagery is elemental without becoming decorative. It feels less like a description of nature than an attempt to construct a small protective mythology around it.

That distinction becomes important because "Lichtung" is not really an album about tranquillity. It is an album about what makes tranquillity possible.

"Vogelfrei" introduces a more restless side of the record, its title suggesting freedom from social or legal constraint, but the lyrics are considerably more complicated than a simple liberation anthem. Rivers have to dry up, bars have to be broken, the crowd has to be abandoned, desire and greed have to be escaped. Freedom here is not a picturesque meadow waiting at the end of the road. It requires severance. One has to leave something behind before one can discover what remains.

That idea leads naturally into "Wiederbelebung", perhaps the album's most revealing title. The word means resurrection or revival, but the song is less interested in miraculous rebirth than in the friction involved in becoming alive again. “You want visibility / I want opposition” is the basic tension, and it is a remarkably good description of hackedepicciotto themselves: two radically different artistic temperaments negotiating a common language without sanding down their differences. The lyrics eventually move from solitude into togetherness, which could almost serve as a manifesto for the entire project.

Musically, this is where the album starts to reveal its real development. hackedepicciotto have always been capable of creating vast, dark atmospheres, but "Lichtung" is less content to let repetition do all the heavy lifting. Electronics are no longer merely an atmospheric coating. They become active participants, sometimes mechanical, sometimes spectral, sometimes surprisingly physical. Hacke's bass provides weight and propulsion while de Picciotto's piano, violin and hurdy-gurdy introduce textures that seem to have wandered into the studio from several centuries at once. The resulting collision is neither folk nor industrial, neither chamber music nor electronica, but a peculiar third territory where those categories become increasingly unhelpful.

"Erntedank" pushes this synthesis further. Its imagery of roots, horses, planets, stars and tides makes existence itself sound like some enormous agricultural ceremony conducted by a slightly distracted cosmos. The title, literally connected to harvest thanksgiving, turns the natural cycle into something almost metaphysical: roots grow, stars cast shadows, tides harvest us. Humanity is not harvesting the world here. The world is harvesting humanity.

Then comes "Zeitenwende", and the record stops pretending that the outside world can be kept outside forever. The German word has become particularly loaded in recent years, describing a historical turning point, and the song approaches that idea without resorting to the usual grandstanding. Time, finitude, wars, fate, fire: the vocabulary is stark. Most strikingly, the past follows like a cat dragging tin cans behind its tail. It is a wonderfully strange image because it turns historical trauma into something both absurd and unavoidable. We do not simply remember the past; we hear it rattling behind us whenever we move.

The music responds accordingly. What might have become an obvious political statement instead develops into something more ambiguous and emotionally durable. There is melancholy, tension and a sense of irreversible movement, but also a strange tenderness. The album's turning point is not the discovery of an answer. It is the acceptance that nothing will return exactly to what it was.

That is perhaps where hackedepicciotto's long nomadic history becomes most relevant. After fourteen years of movement, settling down is itself a radical gesture. Not because staying put is inherently virtuous, but because stopping changes one's relationship with time. A traveller accumulates places; a resident accumulates layers. "Lichtung" sounds like a record made at the moment those two forms of memory collide.

The instrumental "Draussen" consequently feels like the album's great paradox. “Outside” should be the expansive counterpart to the protected clearing, yet the music makes the exterior world feel unstable, immense and physically present. Bass, strings, electronics and percussion gradually gather into something more insistent, almost threatening, before the tension begins to dissolve. The clearing is not a bunker. Its walls are imaginary.

"Einig" offers a different possibility. Conflict does not disappear; it transforms. The lyrics describe the stubborn spark of disagreement becoming something lighter when the force of unity creates a bond stronger than discord. It is an unusually mature proposition because it does not demand harmony at all costs. Difference remains. What changes is its function.

And then "Der Marschall" closes the record instrumentally, leaving the listener with no lyrical conclusion, no neatly packaged wisdom, no musical equivalent of a therapist handing over a certificate saying Congratulations, You Have Processed Your Feelings. Instead, there is atmosphere, repetition and an unresolved sense of watchfulness.

The decision to write the album entirely in German is crucial. For de Picciotto, an American who has spent decades in Berlin, this is more than a linguistic experiment. It is an act of belonging, but also of confronting the cultural and historical weight carried by the language. English had offered a certain freedom; German imposes different contours. Rather than disguising that constraint, "Lichtung" uses it as a compositional tool. The words become denser, stranger and more physical. Even without understanding every syllable, their cadence becomes part of the architecture.

That makes "Lichtung" feel less like a departure from hackedepicciotto's previous work than like a reorganisation of it. The nomadic years are still here. So are the darkness, the experimental instincts, the ritual atmosphere, the cinematic scale and the fascination with the border between acoustic and electronic sound. What has changed is the centre of gravity. The duo no longer seems compelled to search for somewhere else.

Perhaps that is the quiet achievement of the record. "Lichtung" does not celebrate arrival as the end of movement. It treats arrival as a new form of movement, one that happens inwardly rather than geographically. The clearing is temporary, the storms are still there, history keeps rattling its absurd tin cans, and the world outside remains perfectly capable of losing its mind. But for a while there is a garden, a piano, a few strange electronic noises, two voices negotiating the same piece of darkness, and enough light to see where the trees end.

After fourteen years on the road, that may be as close to a revolution as one reasonably gets: staying somewhere long enough to hear it change.



SINE: La Mordre

More reviews by
Artist: SINE (@)
Title: La Mordre
Format: CD & 12" + Download
Label: Metropolis (@)
Rated: * * * * *
There is something deliciously suspicious about "La Mordre". SINE, the Austin-based project of multi-instrumentalist Rona Rougeheart, builds electronic music around sub-bass, heavy beats, industrial textures and a sharp sense of theatricality, but underneath the glamour there is always something with teeth. Her new album for Metropolis Records turns that tension into a narrative about ambition, seduction and the dangerous attraction of success. Rougeheart imagines a character chasing the big breakthrough, gradually discovering that the price of getting there may involve surrendering rather more than expected. The story is present, but never suffocatingly explained: it lives inside the music.

“Goddess” establishes the atmosphere with sleek menace, while “Perilized” introduces a more spectral dimension. From there, “Succumb To Me”, “2 Die 4” and “Trauma Bondage” sharpen the album's central contradiction: the music is designed to attract the body while the lyrics keep whispering that perhaps we should be suspicious. This is where SINE is particularly effective. Desire and danger are rarely presented as opposites. They are two sides of the same mechanism, and Rougeheart knows exactly how much temptation a good bassline can conceal.
Her concept of “Electronic Boom” is useful here, although "La Mordre" is considerably broader than a genre tag might suggest. Industrial electronics, dark pop, EBM-adjacent rhythms, cinematic atmospheres and more sensual passages constantly exchange places. Rougeheart's background as a drummer and multi-instrumentalist is important: the rhythms feel physical rather than merely programmed, while the voice behaves less like a conventional lead vocal than another component of the machinery. She can sound seductive, confrontational, detached or almost playful, sometimes within the same song.

That last quality saves the album from becoming overly solemn. Rougeheart has a well-developed taste for sarcasm and humour, and tracks such as “Immortal Disco” embrace the absurdity of the record's glamorous darkness. It is a useful counterweight to songs dealing with cruelty, trauma, obsession and control. Human beings have always enjoyed dancing while contemplating terrible decisions, so there is something reassuringly traditional about it.

The production, divided between Rougeheart and collaborators including Curse Mackey and AwareNess, gives the album enough variety without sacrificing cohesion. Mark Pistel's mastering provides additional definition to the heavy low end, but the record never becomes simply an exercise in sonic weight. The more effective moments are those in which attractive surfaces conceal uncomfortable ideas. “Blood + Wine” is seductive without becoming innocent; “Cruel” turns unpleasantness into something almost irresistibly danceable; “Bodies” brings the album's fascination with physicality closer to the foreground.

The title itself offers the appropriate metaphor. "La Mordre" evokes biting, and the entire album revolves around the transformation of desire into appetite. Stardom appears first as glitter, then as temptation, finally as something capable of changing the person who wants it. Rougeheart does not turn this into a conventional morality tale. There is no reassuring lesson waiting at the end, only the increasingly blurred boundary between wanting power and becoming consumed by it.

That ambiguity is one of the record's greatest strengths. SINE understands that darkness is more convincing when it does not constantly announce how dark it is. The music can be sensual, funny, aggressive and genuinely uneasy without having to choose one personality. It can invite you onto the dance floor while quietly questioning why you wanted to go there in the first place.

"La Mordre" therefore feels less like a collection of industrial-electronic tracks than a carefully staged descent into temptation. It is sleek without being sterile, theatrical without becoming camp, accessible without surrendering its sharper edges. Most importantly, it understands that seduction works better than intimidation. You do not have to be forced into the darkness. Sometimes the darkness simply offers you a drink. And if the drink happens to contain blood and wine, well, the warning was there. You just chose not to read it.



Mick Harris & Martyn Bates: Murder Ballads [Incest Songs]

More reviews by
Artist: Mick Harris & Martyn Bates (@)
Title: Murder Ballads [Incest Songs]
Format: 12" x 2 + Download
Label: Sub Rosa (@)
Rated: * * * * *
There are family reunions one should probably avoid.

The four stories collected on "Murder Ballads [Incest Songs]" involve forbidden desire, murder, betrayal, accidental incest and the sort of inherited misery that makes even the Brothers Grimm seem like candidates for family therapy. Yet the remarkable thing about Mick Harris and Martyn Bates is that they do not treat these old songs as lurid curiosities. They strip away almost everything that could make them conventionally entertaining and leave behind something far stranger: voices suspended in darkness, surrounded by sound so sparse and deep that the traditional ballad begins to feel less like folklore than a memory someone is trying unsuccessfully to forget.

Originally recorded as the third part of the "Murder Ballads" trilogy, "Incest Songs" completes a project Harris and Bates developed across the 1990s, following "Drift" and "Passages". The trilogy drew on the old European and Anglo-American tradition of murder ballads, those cheerfully catastrophic songs in which betrayal, incest, drowning and homicide tend to turn up before the second verse has properly introduced everyone. The original trilogy was later gathered into a complete collection, and its place in the histories of dark ambient, industrial music and experimental folk has become increasingly evident with time.

The partnership itself is an unlikely but remarkably coherent one. Mick Harris emerged from the extreme end of British music, most famously through Napalm Death, before developing his Lull project into a form of deep, glacial ambient music in which rhythm was stretched until it became almost geological. Martyn Bates, meanwhile, came from Eyeless in Gaza, bringing with him a very different history of post-punk, experimental pop, poetry and intensely idiosyncratic vocal work. Put them together and you get neither conventional folk nor conventional ambient music, but a strange third thing in which the song seems to have been left outside in the snow until only its skeleton returned.

"Incest Songs" is the most radical expression of that idea. The previous volumes often relied on the tension between Bates' voice and a relatively isolated instrumental presence. Here, that separation disappears. Bates effectively multiplies himself. Voices overlap, answer one another, retreat into the background and reappear at different distances. There is no longer one singer delivering a narrative to an audience. There are several versions of the same consciousness occupying the same haunted room. That changes everything.

In “The Bonny Hind”, the traditional story is already disturbing enough, but Harris refuses to underline the horror with theatrical accompaniment. Instead, the music seems to suspend the song inside an enormous, slow-moving darkness. Bates' vocal lines are fragile but never weak. They carry the peculiar authority of someone reciting something that has been remembered for so long that the distinction between personal memory and inherited story has vanished. The effect is hypnotic rather than dramatic.

This is important because "Murder Ballads" could very easily have become gothic theatre. The titles alone provide enough ammunition for an entire wardrobe of black lace, candles and questionable life choices. Harris and Bates wisely resist all of that. Their darkness is not decorative. It comes from subtraction.

“Sheaf and Knife” deepens the sense of unease. The narrative contains the sort of moral catastrophe that old ballads routinely handled with astonishing efficiency, but the music slows everything down until the consequences seem to lose their chronological order. Voices emerge from voices. Words become fragments of sound. The story is still there, but it is no longer the only thing happening. This is where Bates becomes particularly extraordinary.

His voice has always possessed an unusual relationship with fragility. He can sound intimate without sounding confessional, theatrical without sounding mannered. Here, the extensive layering produces something almost choral, except that the choir consists of one person repeatedly confronting himself. The resulting harmonies are not lush in the conventional sense. They are blurred, imperfect, slightly unstable, as if several memories were trying to occupy the same sentence. Harris supplies the environment in which this can happen. His contribution is less a backdrop than a gravitational field. The low frequencies move slowly, sometimes almost imperceptibly, creating an acoustic pressure that gives Bates' voice somewhere to float. There is a remarkable amount of empty space, but it never feels vacant. The silence has weight. The bass seems to extend beyond the audible boundaries of the music, turning the listening space into something larger and darker than the physical room.

This is where Harris' history as Lull becomes relevant. His ambient work has often depended on extremely slow processes, but here the drone does not simply induce contemplation. It destabilises the narrative. You begin listening for the story and gradually find yourself listening to the space around it.

“The Two Brothers”, at seventeen minutes, takes this strategy to its furthest point. The extended duration allows the piece to become almost architectural. Bates' voices appear at different depths, creating the sensation of figures moving behind one another rather than a singer standing in front of a microphone.

The result is profoundly strange. Not frightening in the conventional horror-film sense. There are no cheap shocks, no monstrous noises suddenly appearing from the darkness. Instead, the music creates the much more uncomfortable sensation that something human has become slightly unfamiliar.

The ballad itself concerns jealousy and fratricide, but the emotional centre of the performance is not simply violence. It is the way intimacy becomes corrupted. Brothers, lovers, parents and children are supposed to occupy certain emotional categories, and the traditional ballads are full of stories in which those categories collapse catastrophically. Harris and Bates understand that the real horror lies there.

The fourth and longest piece, “Edward”, lasts almost eighteen minutes and functions almost like a final descent. The repeated questioning of the traditional ballad becomes fragmented and spectral, while the vocal layers increasingly blur the distinction between narrator, witness and perpetrator. By this point, the lyrics almost cease to behave as lyrics. Their phonetic qualities become as important as their narrative meaning.

This is one of the album's most impressive achievements: the words never disappear, but they stop being entirely trustworthy. You understand enough to know something terrible has happened. You do not necessarily feel that understanding is helping.

The relationship between the music and the old folk material is consequently more sophisticated than a simple dark-ambient adaptation of traditional songs. Harris and Bates are not modernising the ballads. They are excavating them. What they uncover is not some quaint image of rural superstition but a brutal psychological landscape in which social rules, desire, guilt and violence repeatedly collide.
The old songs were already strange. This music merely removes the daylight.

That is also why the title "Incest Songs" should not be mistaken for an attempt to shock. The taboo is already embedded in the source tradition. What Harris and Bates investigate is what happens when such material is deprived of the narrative speed that normally carries a ballad forward. Slow it down enough, repeat it, layer the voice, surround it with almost immobile electronic tones, and the story begins to feel less like something that happened once and more like something that is happening eternally.

A curse without supernatural machinery.

The current vinyl edition makes that quality particularly apt. Spread over two records, with four lengthy pieces occupying a physical object rather than an abstract stream, "Incest Songs" becomes almost ritualistic. The textured sleeve and marbled vinyl are not merely collector's decoration. They suit a work whose appeal has always involved atmosphere, tactility and the sense of encountering an artefact from somewhere outside ordinary musical time. There is, inevitably, a question about whether a record this slow and austere can remain compelling after several decades. The answer is yes, although it does demand something increasingly unfashionable from the listener: patience.

Nothing here is engineered for instant gratification. There is no obvious “moment”. The music accumulates through tiny shifts in vocal position, harmonic pressure and density. The longer you remain inside it, the more distinctions become audible. A voice that seemed distant becomes intimate. A background layer suddenly takes on melodic significance. A drone that initially appeared static reveals a slow internal movement.

It is not music that rewards impatient sampling.

Humanity has invented the skip button and then spent the next twenty years complaining that nothing has depth anymore. "Incest Songs" would probably find this amusing. What makes the album remarkable, ultimately, is the precision of its restraint. Harris could have made it heavier. Bates could have made the singing more theatrical. The arrangements could have been busier, the electronics more obviously ominous, the production more demonstrative. They chose not to.

Instead, they create a peculiar suspension in which folk memory, voice and electronic resonance become inseparable. The songs are neither preserved nor destroyed. They are transformed into something that feels almost outside historical time. And perhaps that is why the final chapter of the trilogy still sounds so singular.

The project began with murder ballads, but its deepest subject is not murder. It is memory: how stories survive, how violence becomes folklore, how voices carry events across generations, and how the meaning of an old song changes when someone decides to slow it down enough for all its shadows to catch up.

"Incest Songs" is not beautiful in any comfortable sense.

It is beautiful in the way a ruined church can be beautiful at dusk, when the architecture remains but the original purpose has become difficult to recover. It is music haunted by its own source material, but also by the knowledge that some stories refuse to die simply because they are unpleasant. Harris and Bates do not exorcise those stories. They give them somewhere to remain.