Alessandro Bosetti’s "Carnaval 2" is less a sequel than a haunted echo: you hear Schumann’s "Carnaval", but only the dust motes, the treble shadows, the skeletal rhythm bones. Bosetti doesn’t remake it; he erases its faces and lets the bones whisper. Over two hundred years later, he rips off the masks and leaves us with unnamed masks - piano-chapters that no longer carry character labels, but carry the weight of possibility. The mask is now a question, not an answer.
Performed by Reinier van Houdt, and interspersed with Bosetti’s own electro-acoustic “Paraventi” (screens) between chapters, the album is a work of absence as much as presence. Van Houdt’s piano sometimes floats in familiar tones, sometimes fractures as if the keyboard is remembering itself backwards. In the interludes, electronics drift and thrum - soft sighs, subtle static - that feel like the room breathing, or time stretching.
What’s beautiful - and unsettling - is that Bosetti keeps the formal scaffold of "Carnaval"’s chapter structure, but frees each section from its narrative anchor. The numbered chapters aren’t characters now, but blank sigils. The masks are blank: you can don any, or none. It’s as though the composer said: “Here is form. Now you fill it with your own ghosts”. There’s a playful cruelty in that: the score demands identity, but offers none. If you expect Harlequin, you get a trembling chord instead.
Van Houdt is the perfect medium for this project. His touch is liminal: precise when needed, but capable of dissolving into ambiguity. The album’s pacing matters: the short electro-acoustic screens offer breathing room - moments to shift mask, to reset expectations, to catch your breath before the next chapter begins. The transitions matter as much as the piano itself.
There are no lyrics here, so your own mind becomes the narrator. The silence between notes, the half-formed melodic fragments, the choice to erase or to repeat - these are the story. The irony is that removing narrative gives you more narrative; erasing character gives you more possibility. “Who are you?” the music asks. And the answer is: “Maybe everyone. Maybe nobody”.
Bosetti’s catalog shows him as a sculptor of language and sound. He’s worked with speech loops, field recordings, experiments in voice; in "Carnaval 2" he turns to abstraction, to musical language stripped of idiosyncrasy. In doing so, he reveals how loaded the mere structure of "Carnaval" always was. The original masks - Clara, Harlequin, Eusebius - are gone. What remains is structure, emptiness, and the listener’s projection.
If there is a flaw, it’s that the effort to keep everything open risks undercommitment: at times you wish he’d pick a mask and really wear it, instead of floating between them. Some chapters feel hesitant, as though waiting for permission. Others shine exactly because they resist.
In "Carnaval 2", Bosetti gives us a music of possibility. It is music as blank slate, as mirror, as question. It is both invitation and refusal: listen, but don’t be surprised if you don’t recognize yourself. The mask is blank. The music demands you fill it. And perhaps that is a very modern kind of identity.